All theories on flying have to reconcile with gravity.
In my last P.E.P. post I outlined my "bottom-line" theodicy principle. Actually, I have a principle that's an even "bottom-er-line": the ground. [If you didn't get the joke/metaphor, don't worry; you probably weren't the only one]
In other words, although I'm deeply committed to the idea that man is the source of evil, I'm not so committed that I'll deny any and all opposing evidence.
I'm forced to reconcile all my ideas and committments withIn all honesty, this thought scares me. Because what if God isn't good? Or at least, not as good as I thought? What if He really is the source of evil? How can I love and serve a God like that?
the reality proclaimed by the Bible and reason.
For the first few weeks of class, I would get frustrated because everyone kept taking a "faith seeking understanding" approach. In other words, their faith wasn't dependent on the answer to these questions; they were already locked into this belief, regardless of what type of God they were believing in.
And I couldn't share in that sentiment. I refused to believe in or serve a God who instigated evil;
I'd rather turn heretic than serve an evil God.But one day I asked myself, "So what if this is true? What then?"
My initial response was, "Well, don't believe it anymore, duh!"
And then I realized that even if my worst nightmare came true, there's still no where else to turn. There is no other reality I can live in. I know the God of the Bible is alive; I know He is the God of the universe.
So then I said, "Fine; He's real. That doesn't mean I have to serve Him. Maybe I'd lead a revolution, a counter-effort of true goodness!"
And then I remembered ... there's no other foundation of goodness besides God. Ontologically speaking, there is no such thing as goodness besides what God does and is. So even if I were to make my own little standard of goodness, it wouldn't be real. It wouldn't work.
As one of His creations, there's no way for me to live independently of His Creator-ship.
"'You do not want to leave too, do you?' Jesus asked the Twelve. Simon Peter answered him, 'Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. We believe and know that you are the Holy One of God.'" John 6:66-69
"This day I call heaven and earth as witnesses against you that I have set before you life and death, blessings and curses. Now choose life, so that you and your children may
live" Dueteronomy 30:19
live" Dueteronomy 30:19
So really, I'm stuck. This is reality; either embrace it and enjoy life or reject it and suffer death.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Well ... that's kind of a depressing conclusion. Sorry; I don't actually think things are this bleak. I believe that God's goodness truly is good, beautiful, and pleasing! :)
hm hm hm hm hmmmm....i've wrestled with those same things. remember when we saw Star Wars III? that brought a lot of doubts to my mind as to whether God is good--like maybe the evil one is good and God's the liar. *gasp* those were not fun times. if you like, i can look up some of my conclusions in journal entries from then and send them to you via email. :) once more, very well said, Erin!
ReplyDeleteI don't remember the Star Wars III controversy, but I can imagine it wasn't pretty. Yes, please! Definitely let me know what your conclusions on the whole issue! :)
ReplyDeleteOk, this may way of the map… but I don’t have to go work tomorrow so I’m feeling especially philosophical this evening.
ReplyDeleteI’ve always thought that the existence of evil does not necessarily prove that God does NOT exist or that he is the source of evil, but rather, that it proves his ultimate goodness and love. It proves his goodness because without it, there would be no good. Would the notion of “good” even exist if he were not ultimately behind it? It proves his commitment to the entire enterprise of love because he gave us the ability to not love. I’m thinking that God is more interested in “true love” ( said in the voice of the ailing Wesly ) than anything else and is willing to appear to be the cause of man’s evil, given the chance that a few of us sick, twisted puppies will respond in love to all that he has done for us.
Not sure how this all would hold up to Calvinist position, but that never made much sense to me anyway.